Advertisement Daughters of CharityICN Would you like to advertise on ICN? Click to learn more.

Webinar: Catholic approaches to mining - Lessons from cases of impact

  • Dr Severine Deneulin

In October 2025, the Laudato Si Research Institute (LSRI) at Campion Hall, Oxford, and US-based Notre Dame University's Catholic Peacebuilding Network (CPN) together published Catholic Approaches to Mining: A Framework for Reflection, Planning, and Action. The document, co-sponsored by the Vatican's Dicastery for Promoting Integral Human Development, intends to help Church leadership and Catholic organisations to harness their capacity to respond to problems associated with mining and bring hope to affected communities.

A series of case studies was then commissioned to show examples of successful Church action on mining. The case studies come from Peru, Brazil, Democratic Republic of Congo, Philippines, Chile, Peru, Colombia, and Nicaragua. In collaboration with the Jesuits' Justice in Mining Network, LSRI and CDN are hosting a series of online webinars with case study authors presenting their stories and engaging in discussion about lessons learned, best practices, and other experiences.

The first webinar took place Wednesday, 18 November, and focused on the Andes region. Three cases studies were considered.

José Bayardo Chata, Executive Director of DHUMA (Derechos Humanos y Medio Ambiente, Human Rights and Environment) in the province of Puno, Peru, spoke about the Legal Defence of Indigenous Peoples in the south of Peru. Puno is mainly inhabited by rural communities of Quechua and Aymara origin whose ways of life are deeply linked to the land and the high Andean ecosystems. But nearly a third of the Puno region is under mining concessions. The state has systematically granted these concessions without adequate prior consultation processes, despite the fact that International Labour Organisation (ILO) Convention 169, which enshrines the right to such consultation, is legally binding in Peru. Rural communities in Puno have asserted their rights and created legal precedents in favour of prior consultation processes on mining concessions and in respect of the right to Free, Prior, Informed Consent (FPIC).

José Bayardo emphasised in the webinar that legal proceedings were not a matter of lawyers, but above all of an organised community. If the local community is disorganised, there is no leadership and cohesion, and then there can be no legal proceedings. The work of DHUMA in accompanying Indigenous communities to have their rights respected is as much community-based (training in leadership skills, rights education and others) as it is legal.

Edgar Antonio López, Professor, Faculty of Theology at the Pontificia Universidad Javeriana in Bogota, Colombia, spoke about the Quebradona copper mine project in the Diocese of Jericó in the Department of Antioquia, Colombia. In 2007, the South African company AngloGold Ashanti entered the southwest region of the department with the aim of extracting gold and copper. In 2007, it obtained an exploration licence, but, to date, has not received the permit to start operations. The Catholic community, led by its diocesan bishop, has trained local populations in the teachings of integral ecology, and the bishop made eco-theology compulsory in priestly formation. A group of women religious on the ground has been accompanying local community members in preventing the illegal attempts of the company to start drilling activities. The case demonstrates the impact of community formation and mobilisation. Community support has been encouraged by formation in integral ecology and consciousness-raising about the environmental impacts of mining, especially on water. This is especially important in the context of community division about the potential benefits of mining in their region. Gold and copper mining might bring some revenues for some people for some time, but when the water is polluted and forest and soil destroyed as a consequence of mining, there is no life for anyone.

Edgar López highlighted in the webinar that the assets of the Church are at the formation and moral level, but that the Church never acts alone. It is never separated from the wider civil society and always acts together with other organisations. He also noted that the work is never completed once and for all and that local communities need to be watchful. This is not only a task for the Catholic Church alone, but of the whole community who see their lives being threatened.

Cristián Borgoño Barros, Assistant Professor of Theological Ethics in the School of Theology at the Pontifical Catholic University of Santiago, Chile, spoke about the Pascua-Lama project in the Chilean Diocese of Copiapó. This project is a major transnational gold-silver open-pit initiative by Canadian company Barrick Gold on the Chile-Argentina border. Despite Chile's deep cultural and economic identification with mining, the diocese of Copiapó emerged as a significant voice defending the Huasco Valley's water resources, particularly glaciers, which were threatened by the project. Through grassroots accompaniment, the diocese's pastoral action for the safeguarding of creation, led largely by religious sisters and lay catechists, mobilised local farming communities. Key actions included public education via homilies, radio broadcasts, murals, marches, and travelling from community to community in a large, sparsely populated area; and alliances with other civil society organisations. This mobilisation ultimately led to the project's definitive closure in 2020. The response evolved from local concerns into a coordinated diocesan effort, emphasising the right to water, care for our Common Home, and rejection of mining donations to avoid conflicts of interest. This case stands out as an exceptional prophetic witness within Chile's generally mining-friendly ecclesial context, demonstrating how a small, resource-limited diocese could challenge powerful economic and political interests through faith-inspired, non-violent resistance and ecological advocacy.

In the webinar, Cristián Borgoño underlined the non-partisan aspect of the mobilisation. It is not about party politics, but about defending the way of life of people who are threatened. In Copiapó, the Church was making its own the needs of the people. The mining activities were threatening water sources and the need for water was a matter of life and death. He also noted that the symbolic aspects of Catholic life, such as novenas and liturgies, were important visible points of the mobilisation to defend the glaciers, and hence the life of all, in the Huasco valley. Similarly to the other two contributions, the importance of alliances of the Church with other civil society organisations could not be emphasised enough. The defence of life is a concern of the whole People of God.

Further webinars will consider case studies from the Amazon, Central America, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo and the Philippines. The next webinar will be on Tuesday 1st December at 4pm UK time.

Register here:
https://lsri.campion.ox.ac.uk/events/lessons-amazon-and-central-america-case-studies-catholic-approaches-mining

The Framework document and case studies can all be found at: https://lsri.campion.ox.ac.uk/research/mining

Adverts

The Archbishop Romero Trust

We offer publicity space for Catholic groups/organisations. See our advertising page if you would like more information.

We Need Your Support

ICN aims to provide speedy and accurate news coverage of all subjects of interest to Catholics and the wider Christian community. As our audience increases - so do our costs. We need your help to continue this work.

You can support our journalism by advertising with us or donating to ICN.

Mobile Menu Toggle Icon