Bethlehem: An ocupational blow

Heavily armed solders check children going to and from school each day. Image CPT
Toine van Teeffelen, Author and Pax Christi partner at the Arab Education Institute in Bethlehem writes: Dirar Aliyan was fast asleep. It was the night of Wednesday to Thursday, November 4-5, a few weeks ago. The setting: a small village near Tulkarem, in the northern part of the occupied West Bank. Aliyan was staying there during the days when he worked from his office as president of Najah University for Vocational and Technical Training.
Suddenly, he had a nightmare which turned out not to be a nightmare, as Amira Hass reported in Haaretz: Israeli soldiers had entered his house and his room and beaten him, striking him on the neck and chest. Later, after visiting the hospital, he would say that the pain was more mental than physical. The army had been looking for his nephew, who lived on another floor of the building.
The IDF later claimed that the soldiers had first asked Aliyan to show his ID (a lie), and that there was no evidence of violence (because there were no photographs...).
Hass writes that according to Palestinian sources during that same night, November 4-5, the army carried out no less than 42 raids on the West Bank within a 24-hour period, targeting villages, neighbourhoods and homes. This is not Gaza, but the threat is growing on the West Bank as well.
What strikes me most is Aliyan's statement that the incident had affected him more mentally than physically. The trauma lies not only in the suddenness of the raid and the blows, but also in the humiliation. What lies behind those blows? Partly resentment and revenge, but it also has to do with habit, with the routine exercise of an excess of power that has become self-evident across generations of Israelis.
The occupation has been going on for a long time, almost sixty years now. The vast majority of Palestinians in the West Bank (and in Gaza) have never known anything other than occupation. For Israelis, the fact that they can exercise almost total power over other people has become ingrained from an early age. (October 7 was, in itself, a rude awakening.) So has the sense that they do not have to account for their actions: afterwards, you simply fill in a form denying everything.
Another thing behind those blows is the severing of all human contact. Afterwards, Aliyan wondered aloud: why didn't they simply ask who I was?
I have the feeling that almost everyone in the West Bank, let alone in Gaza, carries some psychological scar as a result of personal humiliations - the 'blows' one receives - which can also shape a person's character to some extent. In my own surroundings, in the city of Bethlehem, these experiences are mainly associated with checkpoints: soldiers treating people inhumanely, like cattle; making you wait, insulting, mocking you, shouting, or playing tricks. You do develop a certain "callus" on your soul, and you would rather not talk about it, but all the same: it sometimes runs deep. Mary is used to say: that whole permit system for traveling was wrong from the beginning, it made us into slaves.
And it of course also matters whether or not you can do something about it. Aliyan has a British passport in addition to his Palestinian one. This gives him room for manoeuvring and access to contacts, as is also the case with residents of Qusra, Taybeh and other villages in the West Bank, many of whom also hold American passports. (Many people do everything they can to obtain a second passport, also so that they can leave if things become desperate.)
Everyone knows someone in their family or immediate surroundings who has been imprisoned by Israel. If only because someone failed to obey an order, or because young people threw stones.
Someone once told me that checkpoints are the great equalizer. It doesn't matter whether you are a president or a labourer: everyone is treated equally, in democratic fashion. With or without a blow.
LINK
Haaretz: Palestinian University President says he was beaten during IDF raid in West Bank

















